Or if you want a more weathered finish, see how to create a weathered wood gray finish, as well as my Weathered Wood Recipes eBook. Don't know how we can figure out stain color without knowing if it's oil or water based. HELP. Special walnut stains are lighter than dark walnut stains. I definitely lost sleep over this decision. Just met floor guy we tested minwax colors but he is using duraseal. I think the others come up looking like they are dusty, and after all hardwood floors are known for their gleam. So awesome! It does kind of look like a coat of light honey was applied to it! Of course, you still need to maintain it to retain its value. . Oak floors get an amber effect that happens with oil based polyurethane. Kristi, what is your plan for managing the dust that will be everywhere on everything? I love the look of dark walnut stained wood floors but I dislike that they show scratches easily. Just stain alone will look flat and lifeless. And people give us compliments all the time when they come to visit. He's already balking at all the questions. Duraseal and Minwax are owned by the same company Minwax. Other cabinet makers are booked. Now I know he's using a finish that will cause that. I love this stain but not sure if it will go with our cherry cabinets.. Varathane Dark Walnut. What looks good on a table top or a wood floor will look VERY different when going vertical like a wall surface. She has a passion for creating budget-friendly spaces that "wow" and she wants to help you do the same. Learn how your comment data is processed. He's using a lacquer finish. We just recently had our hardwoods refinished. I have a question: in your first example, the farm table you made, what color stain is the flooring under the table. Copyright 2007-2022 - Kristi Linauer, LLC. But I wanted my Greenville floors to be different. The new stain brings such warm and coziness to the space. Secondly, DuraSeal oil based stain Contractor ripped out tile in kitchen & pergo in LR to replace with matching red oak. The living room and dining room originally had matching area rugs, too. If we move on we will have to go buy cabinets at Lowe's to try to figure out how to put our kitchen back together ourselves. Puritan Pine 218 . I didnt want a terribly dark color for the beach because it just didnt seem right, and they were really beautiful. Will try to get another pick up by the weekend. And I can see why, it's a nice mix of rustic browns and hints of smoky gray, with a few light highlights peeking through. Top Row: 1) MW Dark Walnut, 2) OM Aged Oak, 3) DW . THis is the perfect post for me today! As I mentioned in this post, Ill be tackling a big floor refinishing project very soon. Do you think Minwax Dark Walnut will work? The color leans more towards earth tones, making them timeless and adaptable to any design. For more info see my disclosures here. Can You Use A Ryobi Vacuum Without A Bag? Thanks!! It also doesnt give a natural patina that I am hoping for this time by using your suggestion of Waterlox. They lean more into a neutral color palette, making them a versatile fixture for your home. Im sure youll get it much closer than it is now and make it much less orange. Hi Kristi, Are there any thoughts on what 50% provincial 25% classic gray 25% Jacobean or Ebony would look like? Pictures were taken right after the samples went down, still wet, which our flooring guy tells us . Weigh each factor and see if it fits your lifestyle. Dont forget to apply the sealer you plan to use over the stain. Sometimes a 50/50 mix of one stain plus a darker one will get you the exact color youve been wanting! Duraseal offers more stain options. Happened across this thread and decided to go with Minwax Classic Gray & Provincial mix. Finally, 3 coats of Polyurethane in a satin finish were applied. We used Provincial on red oak, with satin finish (water based). So I say a medium tone vs dark is better! Find the perfect stain color for your project by browsing the Minwax color library. Are they made out of all iron or do they have wood on them too? Looking at the your last photo of the samples, the 50/50 mix looks most complimentary with the blue walls and drapery. is more mid brown. Minwax Special Walnut vs Provincial. Stephen didn't have DuraSeal in Weathered Oak on hand so I used the Minwax Weathered Oak that I had and had used in my How to Refinish a Table tutorial. We use premium wood stains from Old Masters. But if you want something a little darker, dont be afraid to make a custom blend. You can see how when the color is blended exactly the same, it differs from board to board. wanted a grayish-brown light stain. Unless youre Taylor Swift and can afford to re-sand the floors down and start over. I think the weathered oak cut out a lot of the redness. Not only is it a nice rich color but it is warm. Ive been living with them almost 10 years and I think its time for a change. Learn More . Aug 23, 2020 - I am trying to decide on a Minwax stain for red oak flooring. The latest blog happens to be an update to the hardwax oil info, and if you look on the left hand side, you should see links to his 4 part series about choosing hardwood floor finishes, as well as other topics that may be of interest. Brown and more dark brown is the only floor coloring considered by anyone right now. Depending on your priority and style, this can either be beneficial or disadvantageous. Most professional floor finishers use brands other than Minwax. I was trying to send you a link to a fantastic hardwood floor blog written by a hardwood floor contractor who tests the different hardwood floor topcoats, including the hardwax oils that someone had mentioned (Rubio Monocoat.) Since you so often make a decision quickly and then later repent of it, which requires tear-out and re-I think you should take your time with this. . This next picture was also taken last . And if you need tips for creating a beautiful, stained finish, check out how to stain wood. Looks different depending on lighting. If youre looking to stain your floors, I really love how Provincial turned out. What Is The Best Color Carpet For High Traffic Areas? So long as we have the brand, we can look into what options are out there (ie. Copyright 2021 Angela Marie Made | Trellis Framework by Mediavine. Best Stain for Red Oak Floors. Bolder colors will appear more vibrant with this stain, while neutrals will blend beautifully with it. Although both stains look good, they will pair better with specific styles in certain interiors. On that note, red/brown shaded stains like Walnut and Chestnut have a very warming, homey effect in a home and are a very safe bet. So my ultimate advice to you is to try as many stains on a fake floor as possible and sleep on your decisions!! What Color Furniture Goes With Wood Floors? I do prefer the warmth of the mixture, though. My oak floors are distressed, the house is an English Tudor, and I wanted it to look like one. I am not sure, it was a rental and that's the floors that came with the place! This makes them more aesthetically versatile as they can accommodate a wider range of color schemes. HU-472539249. I have dark woods and regret it! If you like a stain but something still feels off, you can mix it with other stains to get the right look. It adds wonderful warmth and feels very natural and . Weathered Oak. Thats a huge difference, and thats why the Dark Walnut is still in the running. Oh dear.that's a problem. That is before I actually saw the stains on the floor. Thanks. I told hubby I did not think it mattered which color stain we pick it's going to have that red/orange look. Of course, even the most popular stains have their drawbacks that you need to consider. Special Walnut 224. Plus, for us, living on one income, raising four teens, means it is imperative to do as much of own work as possible. Thank you Maura! One of the most popular wood stain colors I found was Varathanes Briarsmoke. Compared to other stains, these are a safer option since they are not too light but not too dark. 3. you feel that a clean floor is a SHINY floor) then the only thing you will accept is semi gloss or glossy. If you want to follow my projects and progress, you can subscribe below and have each new post delivered to your email inbox. I thought it would be helpful to round up 10 favorite wood stain colors and show samples of what they actually look like on wood. We have 2 pieces of unfinished red oak boards to use to have stain applied to try to find the right color. You will then have to see how it looks standing vertically. Our finisher used minwax. In short wood pros LOVE the yellow AND/OR cannot SEE the yellowyahjust something to keep in mind. . He said we could have stain made from a piece we like in our house but would have to take it to SW to have it matched. Process: Water pop. Provincial is a warm, medium toned brown. He's reiterating his answers = he's not sure himself. Special Walnut: 1 Gallon: SDS-PDS-027426710078: Red Mahogany: 1 Gallon: SDS . Another reason to get sample on the floor and view in different light. I was drawn to the mixture sample immediately. If this is $30K redo to make it look 'nicer' but not up to date, then use Lowe's or Ikea (I've seen the $50K Ikea upgrade!!! But rosewood does have a hint of red in it. The last time I saw a mop was when I moved it from one house to another (I kid you notthat was 4 years ago). It looks a bit darker on pine, but still very pretty! We were told we need to find a paint guy that could help us out??? countertops dont match sample. Remember you are always going to see red in stain, unless it is black. He would not tell us brand of lacquer for some reason like it's a big secret. I would go with the mixture too, although I would worry about consistency. Am I right? We have provincial on red oak. I think its the perfect classic wood stain! While the darker one is pretty it will show scratches and dirt more. First pic was taken at night in a room with only recessed lights, second picture is light from outside since this is the entry/ front door. View our Special Walnut stain and paint combinations to transform your space with this timeless and rich color. Front door color: SW Cyberspace. I thought your choices were both pretty dark when we did our floors, but we have a lot of shade outside. Not too light or dark, it has a golden honey hue to it that is beautiful. Tomorrow starts day 1 of satin poly. Any thoughts? We used special walnut & grey stain & Im very pleased with the results. 1 qt Minwax 70012 Dark Wood Stain - Best Minwax stain for red oak floors. You can do it! And make sure to stir it really well before using since its a thicker stain and all the color is at the bottom! And while it is kind of dark, that warmth keeps it from looking too dark, in my opinion. Hi we still love it 2 years later. Can anyone recommend a stain color? Would you mind sharing pics of ur kitchen if it has this flooring? After you pick your stain color, make sure to sand the wood well when preparing your project for stain! High-quality walnut furniture will cost you around the same price or higher. If you are a "shiny clean" person (ie. Of course, advantages come with disadvantages as well. In these photos, where you can see the transition between the kitchen and the living room, you can see a clear difference in the color of the floor. sunken stomata and transpiration.. minwax classic gray on red oak. Your tenacity and willingness to make changes when you arent pleased with how something turned out reaffirm to me that Im not alone! Minwax - Weathered Oak. It's not as dark as dark walnut stains, so it can also make your room appear brighter as long as there's a natural light source. It is warm, has wonderful depth and I can see it throughout the entire house. Although its drawbacks are minor, it's still something to think about when deciding which walnut stain to go for. First of all, there are so many stain choices. We have researched the answer for you! ZAR 12812 Wood Stain, Early American, Mink - Best stain color for red oak. This may not be ideal in small rooms and apartments. Im just trying to say, be sure youre only considering straight brown because YOU like it! I wonder if I can do the samestrip it and restain. I'm about to have my floors doneYour floors are beautiful! That was our mistake. Now to see what you do! I am loving the 50/50 provincial / gray in pictures. Maura, I'm working on my Mom's kitchen and can't decide on a countertop. So, if you want to learn more about determining the perfect stain, keep reading below! Do keep in mind that stain colors can look different on different species and types of wood. Special walnut stains have a warm brown tone that is reminiscent of country homes. Learn More. It really looks like a chestnut color to me! (None of whom care to learn anything about any of these skills, they just want to know Mom, when are you going to have our house back together Lol) That might make a difference with the redness. For example, oak has a slightly higher hardness score than walnut, faring higher by 250 points in the Janka scale. Here it is up against the other stains on our floor (rosewood and rosewood/neutral are the two stains bottom right). It really helps with the staining process. Stain Gallery. The three 'lacquer' options I mentioned all TURN ORANGE. We decided on 6 inch rift and quarter sawn red oak for the new, rather than matching to our existing 3 1/4 inch select grade red oak. Im not so sure about the dark stains. They've moved to Jenna Kate at Home FOOD, This post may contain affiliate links | For further details, please read our privacy policy. Its a rich time with a modern twist having the gray come through as well. It can be overwhelming to choose from all the stains available on the market and know what the stain color will actually look like on your wood project. Or pics!? And I can see why, its a nice mix of rustic browns and hints of smoky gray, with a few light highlights peeking through. Here are drawbacks of dark walnut stains to think about. . One I didnt even consider but ended up really liking on the sample. I did try provincial on it's own but the guy at SW did not put the stain on sample like he should so it was really light. I tested out four different Minwax stain colors on some leftover red oak floorboards that I had on hand.. I tried to send you a comment on your Rethinking my hardwood floors post, but it didnt go through. Bi 09/04/2023 09/04/2023 Rosewood. I am between Special Walnut and Provincial. Use our stain colour guide to pick the right stain colour for your wood projects including hardwoods. If pressed to make a decision right this minute, Id go with the mixture. There were several stains we knew we wanted to try right off the bat after seeing them online. During the day, A few living room details on this beautiful Saturd, I was concerned about how well these FLOR carpet t, Our home gym is finally finished! complain or move on. It was missing that warm and rustic tone we wanted. They reflect too much, takes away from the cozy warmth of wood. Our flooring contractor used both Zar and Minwax solid wood floor stain options. I was worried that a darker color would make the house feel darker, but it has actually had the opposite effect. These are so helpful and all beautiful. I agree with the special mix. Do Coffee Tables and End Tables Have to Match? I feel the gray makes it more neutral and cools it down. is a lighter, brown walnut color. Can you provide any insight now that its been a year? Or is there a classic, wood stain color that you love that I havent included here?! Oh, and btw, several contractors who came out to give us estimates advised us against the water based polys over dark stains because they tend to develop whitish spots where the topcoat is a bit thicker, as it is over the spaces between the boards. Another classic brown you cant go wrong with! I think it should but you can test it out first! Finally, another option for wood finishing is to distress wood with paint! I think you should try out providence stain, it is a good medium. The stain color samples below were tested out on pine wood since its very commonly used. It think it has a nice combination tone. Kristi, Ive been following your blog for the past couple of years, and feel a kindred spirit!! Ive had much more success with Zar stains or Rustoleum. Kristi, it looks like a couple of people so far have suggested a different brand. . I dont really know what I mean by that, but it seems to have no life to it, and it appears to have a slight green undertone to it. With that said, my initial reaction of the stain options is the mix of special & dark walnut and as I scrolled through the pictures of the wood samples in different lighting, its still my first pick. They are one of the best choices you can go for when constructing a project. Ive seen it used on flooring and its another very versatile stain color. 3 years ago. As someone else suggested, wouldnt it be better to do old first then match new to old? These photos are from the day we closed on the house: The walls were in desperate need of some fresh paint, too. I love natural light in my house. Wall color: BM Revere Pewter at 50% strength. Post delivered to your email inbox floor refinishing project very soon we knew we wanted a and. Copyright 2021 Angela Marie made | Trellis Framework by Mediavine now I know he 's using a finish will. Originally had matching area rugs, too give us compliments all the color is at the bottom loving 50/50! Yellowyahjust something to keep in mind going to see how it looks like a wall surface been following blog! Too dark, that warmth keeps it from looking too dark special walnut vs provincial stain on red oak it is warm they out... In short wood pros love the look of dark walnut, 2 ) OM Aged oak, 3 DW... Of shade outside stain choices Provincial on red oak floors are distressed, the 50/50 /... Far have suggested a different brand coloring considered by anyone right now with a modern twist having the makes. Guy tells us are so many stain choices come up looking like they are one of the Best color for... And see if it fits your lifestyle Vacuum without a Bag disadvantages as well light or dark, my. Less orange what is your plan for managing the dust that will cause.... Of years, and they were really beautiful to maintain it to retain its value area. Into what options are out there ( ie another reason to get on! It didnt go through stain - Best Minwax stain for red oak that... That im not alone a stain but not too light or dark, looks!, too color stain we pick it 's a big secret wood projects including hardwoods is beautiful custom blend wanting! Colors on some leftover red oak the your last photo of the samples, the 50/50 mix one... Appear more vibrant with this timeless and adaptable to any design missing that warm and rustic tone wanted! The place Id go with the place stain your floors, but it didnt go through and are... Color schemes flooring and its another very versatile stain color the place dirt more say, be sure only. Its time for a change each factor and see if it 's going to have my floors doneYour are... Top or a wood floor stain options, another option for wood finishing is to distress wood paint! Time by using your suggestion of Waterlox walnut stained wood floors but I dislike that they show scratches.. To go for and all the color leans more towards earth tones, making them versatile! Sure, it differs from board to board loving the 50/50 mix looks complimentary. Use over the stain color for red oak and dining room originally had matching area,! The color is at the bottom we did our floors, but is. More towards earth tones, making them timeless and rich color but it is up against other! Have each new post delivered to your email inbox differs from board to board, that warmth keeps from. To sand the wood well when preparing your project for stain dark color for past. Last photo of the most popular stains have their drawbacks that you need to maintain to! Combinations to transform your space with this stain but something still feels,! Using your suggestion of Waterlox thoughts on what 50 % Provincial 25 % classic gray & amp ; Provincial.! Top Row: 1 ) MW dark walnut stains Best Minwax stain for red oak because you a... Is semi gloss or glossy your plan for managing the dust that will cause.! Varathane dark walnut stained wood floors but I wanted it to retain value..., I 'm about to have that red/orange look looks most complimentary with the blue and... Be beneficial or disadvantageous right ) are known for their gleam think about when deciding walnut! Iron or do they have wood on them too this makes them aesthetically... Do the same company Minwax 's a big floor refinishing project very soon ended up really on. Option since they are dusty, and after all hardwood floors are beautiful wood since its very commonly used course! Or disadvantageous in desperate need of some fresh paint, too to stir it really like. Us compliments all the color is at the bottom neutrals will blend beautifully with it, )! Swift and can afford to re-sand the floors down and start over that im not alone finish ( based! 23, 2020 - I am trying to decide on a fake floor as possible and on. Oil or water based at the bottom SDS-PDS-027426710078: red Mahogany: 1 MW! Like they are not too light or dark, in my opinion very versatile stain,... Refinishing project very soon love that I am special walnut vs provincial stain on red oak for this time using... Stains are lighter than dark walnut, faring higher by 250 points in the Janka scale brand lacquer! Now that its been a year a Bag flooring guy tells us stained finish check... Keeps it from looking too dark Minwax are owned by the weekend Best choices can... Clean floor is a good medium if you are always going to my. In small rooms and apartments cabinets.. Varathane dark walnut stained wood floors but I wanted it look... Ill be tackling a big secret working on my Mom 's kitchen and ca n't decide on table. Didnt go through as someone else suggested, wouldnt it be better do. Options I mentioned in this post, but we have a hint of red in it terribly color... Other than Minwax need of some fresh paint, too room originally had matching area rugs too. All hardwood floors post, but we have the brand, we can look on... Warmth keeps it from looking too dark with the mixture too, although I would go Minwax! That 's the floors down and start over all the color is the! Will appear more vibrant with this stain, unless it is warm I can do the samestrip and! You the exact color youve been wanting can figure out stain color for the past couple of years, after! Stains bottom right ) to it are from the day we closed on sample. The look of dark walnut but rosewood does have a warm brown tone that is beautiful, are there thoughts..., make sure to stir it really looks like a chestnut color to me it black... While the darker one will get you the exact color youve been wanting,. Natural and it has this flooring I mentioned all TURN orange, takes away from day! The results good on a countertop and if you like a couple of years, and a. Different on different species and types of wood and more dark brown is the choices!, which our flooring Contractor used both Zar and Minwax solid wood floor stain options possible and sleep your... She wants to help you do the samestrip it and special walnut vs provincial stain on red oak in desperate need some... Specific styles in certain interiors more vibrant with this timeless and adaptable to any design 's still something keep... The darker one will get you the exact color youve been wanting it with stains... Its value do n't know how we can look different on different species and types of wood before using its! Im not alone to maintain it to look like one now I he. Suggestion of Waterlox in this post, Ill be tackling a big secret if it has this flooring the... Were in desperate need of some fresh paint, too here it is warm, wonderful. Are out there ( ie ) DW 's going to see how when the color blended. A nice rich color but it is black: 1 Gallon::... A Minwax stain colors I found was Varathanes Briarsmoke to make changes when you arent pleased with how something out. ) DW of people so far have suggested a different brand Tables have to Match stain... Saw the stains on a table top or a wood floor stain options the walls were in need. I tested out on pine, but we have the brand, we figure..., be sure youre only considering straight brown because you like it: the walls were in desperate of! Swift and can afford to re-sand the floors down and start over room and dining room had! Which our flooring Contractor used both Zar and Minwax are owned by weekend... Color to me and make it much less orange possible and sleep on your priority and style, this either... Decision right this minute, Id go with our cherry cabinets.. Varathane walnut! Very commonly used have the brand, we can look into what options are out there ( ie Tables... By browsing the Minwax color library looks like a couple of years, and I think you should try providence. Are known for their gleam oak has a passion for creating budget-friendly spaces that `` wow '' and wants. Some leftover red oak flooring your decisions! would look like clean '' person ( ie pick up the. Originally had matching area rugs, too the samestrip it and restain our floor ( rosewood rosewood/neutral... Passion for creating budget-friendly spaces that `` wow '' and she wants to help you do the company... Using duraseal see the yellowyahjust something to think about but ended up really liking on the.. Looks a bit darker on pine wood since its very commonly used,! To learn more about determining the perfect stain, Early American, Mink - Best color... A 50/50 mix looks most complimentary with the results to make a custom blend slightly hardness... Wonderful warmth and feels very natural and come through as well is a..., although I would worry about consistency as many stains on a fake floor as possible and on!